Dispensational History in a Nutshell

Manuel Lacunza (Ben-Ezra)

The most popular theological system in American Evangelicalism today is Dispensationalism. The basic tenants of the dispensationalist system were first pioneered by a Jesuit scholar Manual Lacunza, who pretended to be a converted Jew (Juan Josafat Ben-Ezra) in Chile during the early 1800s. Lacunza published a book in Spanish called The Coming of Messiah in Glory and Majesty , with the aim toward countering the Reformation claim that the Pope of Rome was the Antichrist of the book of Revelation. The work of Lacunza popularized the futurist interpretation of the book of revelation (that was pioneered by Jesuit Francisco Ribera during the Reformation) and was centered upon the failure of the Church and the restoration of the ethnic Jews to Israel. Edward Irving, a Scottish pastor and founder of Catholic Apostolic Church and fore-runner of the modern charismatic movement, was so moved by these new revelations that he taught himself Spanish in order to properly translate the prophecy to English. Irving’s primary contribution to the system was the invention of the secret rapture of the church in order to make way for the restoration of Israel by ethnic Jews.

Edward Irving

Prior to Irving, most Jesuit futurists believed that the church would endure the tribulation period. Irving ammended the system after a female member of his Catholic Apostolic Church revealed a in prophetic vision that Christ would return twice – once to remove his apostate church, and then to establish a physical kingdom on the Earth and rule from a restored Israel.

CI Scofield

Irving became a popular prophecy teacher in the UK and had a profound influence over John Nelson Darby – a brilliant scholar and the leader of a Church of England split-off congregation nicknamed the Plymouth Brethren. Darby did not pioneer the dispensational system, but he popularized it through prophecy conferences and brought the system to America. Prophecy conferences became popular in America in the mid-1800s, just after after the Second Great Awakening and the Great Disappointment had burned through Western New York in the early 1800s. The Millerite movement, the wake of Revivalism, and strong opposition to Liberalism combined in the mid-1800s to produce a uniquely American system of religion that still predominates today. From this religious movement came the Scofield Reference Bible and Dallas Theological Seminary.

Lewis Sperry Chafer

The system is as strong today as ever, although, like the Plymouth Brethren of yore, the followers of the system have branched out into many different directions. For all its diversity, most dispensationalists strongly adhere to some basic core principles: 1) inerrancy of Scripture, 2) A Literal interpretation of Scripture, 3) A distinction (or radical separation) between the Old Covenant Nation of Israel and the Church of Christ, and 4) A literal, physical millennial reign of Christ. Of these, #3 is solely unique to the system. There are several other unique characteristics of adherents to the system which usually include: justification without a necessary sanctification, arminianism, a secret rapture of the gentile church before the 7-year tribulation period, several resurrections (rapture, Christ’s return, end of the millennium), and at least two judgments.

The primary American systemizer and most influential leader of dispensationalism is, without controversy, Lewis Sperry Chafer, co-founder of Dallas Theological Seminary.


11 thoughts on “Dispensational History in a Nutshell


    Joe Ortiz’s “End Times Passover” blog (Mar. 9, ’10) is now displaying (for the first time anywhere) a facsimile copy of the “kernel” of Margaret Macdonald’s 1830 handwritten pretrib rapture account!
    The same history-changing account was found in the British Library and is catalogued there as “Margaret McDonald’s Vision.”
    Historian Dave MacPherson, who has researched throughout Scotland and England, tracked it down and obtained a copy of the entire 1830 handwritten document which can now be viewed 180 years later.

    (recently saw the above on the internet)

  2. Pingback: NOT REPLACEMENT…EXPANSION! part 3 « Abraham's Seed

  3. I came over here from Paul’s site. I hadn’t seen this claim before so I did a bit of research the last couple of days on Lacunza. I think you have been taking in by a Reformed urban legend about dispensationalism. I wrote up a response HERE

  4. Mr. Butler has an excellent blog. I highly recommend it.

    In his response to my article above he says that “These ‘articles’ often present dispensationalism as if it is the most diabolical cult to have appeared within the Christian church since the Arian controversy of the 300s.”

    That is not the tone I meant to convey here and I need to revise my article if it is.

    Furthermore, Mr. Butler charges me with not having read the book by Father Lacunza and Edward Irving. That is true. I’ll leave the link here if anyone would like to read it and post a review. I’ll do it myself if I have a chance.

    Comming of Messiah in Glory and Majesty .

    By the way, Paul, what part exactly, of what I wrote, is the Urban Legend?

  5. Pingback: Notes on Hebrews 1:1-3 | Abraham's Seed

  6. Pingback: SP Tragelles and I Duped By Conspiracy Theory? | Abraham's Seed

  7. Pingback: Traditional versus Dispensational Interpretation | Abraham's Seed

  8. Pingback: Baptist Views on the Mosaic Covenant | Abraham's Seed

  9. Pingback: Reblog: Analogy of Faith | Feileadh Mor

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s